Publication Wrangling Tutorial

Publication Wrangling Tutorial

The Educational Modulefor Flight Tracker
In this module, you'll learn how to track and validate your scholars' publications through a process we call Publication Wrangling.

[Note: This is a direct transcription of the video and as such may refer to items on screen at the time in the video.]

Why do we need to wrangle publications? There can be some uncertainty when Flight Tracker pulls the information from PubMed. Publications are matched by name and institution, so especially with common names, you may need to weed out mismatched publications manually.

Also, PubMed only began associating institutional information for all authors, not just the first author, in 2014, so if your scholars were active before then you may have missing publications where they weren’t the first author.

To get to the Publication Wrangler, click the “Wrangle” menu and then click “Publication Wrangler.” If you have a lot of scholars with a lot of publications, this may take several minutes to load.

The first page you see when you get to the Publication Wrangler is this auto approval page. Each scholar with new publications since you last wrangled them is listed, with the PMIDs of their new papers linked to PubMed. If this is your first time wrangling, all of their papers Flight Tracker has pulled from PubMed will be listed here.

This page allows you to skip manual review of publications for scholars you’re relatively sure are correct. Flight Tracker automatically flags anyone with a short or common last name for manual review, because those are more likely to get false matches. A short name may return matches where the short name is part of a longer name, like the name “Rook” returning “Rooker” or “Crook.” But even for those with long or uncommon names, if you have any doubt, you should review them manually.

For example, on this page is the scholar Cosby Stone. Let’s say I think there’s another C. Stone at my institution.

I’m going to decide to handle him manually, so I click the text next to the green check mark, “Override and Handle Manually,” which turns it into a yellow hand with a pen. When I start manually reviewing, this will be one of the records I see.

You can also click on an individual’s name to go straight to their wrangler page.

Once you’re done making sure everyone who should get a manual review will get one, click “Auto-Approve Publications” at the bottom to proceed to the first record you will review. If you want to review them all manually, you can do that by clicking the link just below the button.

A few other recommendations for auto-approving:

  1. You’ll probably want to manually approve many Asian names, which are overrepresented in science, even if they’re longer than four characters.
  2. Manually approve publications for anyone with a known doppelganger at your institution. A “doppelganger” is someone with a similar name to the scholar, so for example Jane A. Doe vs. Jane B. Doe. They may not even be at your institution, because if your institution is listed for any of the authors on a paper, it will count as a match even if the name you’re searching is from somewhere else. If this is a consistent problem, where you’re always pulling in Jane B. Doe’s publications, you can insert the wrong ID in the exclude list, which we’ll discuss later.
  3. Manually approve everyone the first time so you can find these doppelgangers, get familiar with your scholars’ science and common collaborators, and find out if any are missing papers, which may mean you need to add former institutions, or institutions they went to after yours, to the search list.

This is the top portion of an individual scholar’s page. For this module, we’re going to look at Dr. Jerri Rook.

On the left, you can navigate to other scholars’ publication wrangler pages.

At the top, it tells you which institutions are being searched for along with that scholar’s name.

You also have a place to enter citations, which you can look up using a PMID or PMCID, and add them to the scholar’s record. You might need to do this for non-first author publications before 2014, when PubMed started including institution information for all authors, or for publications associated with this author when they were at a different institution.

At the very top of the page, if you want to consistently remove a falsely matched author or title word, you can do so in this text box. As discussed earlier, you might have a Jane A. Doe but Jane B. Doe’s publications keep popping up in Jane A’s record. You can type “JB Doe” into this text box to keep them from matching. If there’s a word so far outside your scholar’s expertise that they would never use it in a paper title, you can enter it here too. This might be useful when you keep getting kidney disease papers for someone who only works in neuroscience, for example.

Scrolling down the page, we get to the actual citations, which are divided between new and existing citations.

There are two or potentially three types of matches Flight Tracker can find for an individual paper, depending on how your Flight Tracker is set up.

First, if the author’s ORCID ID is up to date, it might match that way. In that case, a publication is automatically approved without you having to do anything, because Flight Tracker assumes ORCID information is correct. If it’s not, you can fix it with a process we’ll look at later.

Second, which at the moment is limited to just Vanderbilt, a different institutional process that approves papers can be migrate approved papers into Flight Tracker’s publication records.

The third is the most common, and it’s the PubMed Search. This is the one you may need to manually approve.

We’re now ready to wrangle new publications. There are a few ways to decide if the publication is indeed that scholar’s paper:

  1. First, look at the first and middle initials. If this person is always JM Rook, then JB Rook or MJ Rook is not them.
  2. Second, look at the paper titles. This scholar does mechanistic research in neuroscience or pharmacology. If the paper title is about a clinical trial in kidney disease, it’s probably not hers.
  3. Third, you can look at co-authors. Most scientists will publish with the same co-authors for long portions of their career. For Jerri, co-authors Foster, Conn, Moehle, and so on show up frequently.
  4. When in doubt, click on the PubMed link at the end of the citation to verify.

Once you’re on the PubMed page for that paper, you can verify that 1) the author’s name and middle initial are correct, and 2) the author’s affiliation is correct. You will need to click “expand” next to the word “affiliations” to view this information.

If you find a publication that shouldn’t be part of that scholar’s record, simply uncheck the green box next to the citation.

When you’re done with that scholar’s publications, click the green “Finalize Publications” box. This will take a moment to save, then it will move you to the next record with new citations you decided to handle manually.

If you realize you did something wrong, all is not lost. There are instructions for fixing citations that were accepted or excluded in error at the top of every page.

To fix a publication’s status, click the “reset” button at the lower right of each publication to reset it for wrangling. Click “Finalize Publications,” then use the search bar or dropdown on the left of the page to navigate back to that scholar’s record. The publication or publications you reset will now be shown as new publications.

You can also REDCap link at the end of the citation. This will take you to a REDCap form for that paper. Depending on what you did earlier, the “Include?” button will be checked yes or no. Yes means it was accepted as part of a scholar’s record, no means it was excluded. Change the answer as needed and save.

The Publication Wrangler allows you fine control over your scholar’s publication records. You can wrangle it as frequently as you wish, but remember that this data feeds the publication HTML widget, so if a publication isn’t wrangled, it isn’t shown on that widget, if you’re using it.

Scholars also have the opportunity to confirm unwrangled publications via survey or their Scholar Portal.

When you send out a survey, which is covered in a different training video, your scholar will see a list of their publications and be able to confirm any new ones listed.

They can also log in to their Scholar Portal at any time and confirm or reject any new publications. They can also add publications manually.

Questions
Email the Edge team at info@edgeforscholars.org
upcoming Publication Wrangling Tutorial events [ view all events ]
December 7, 2026 | 1:00 pm (In-Person) Dr. Todd Edwards & Dr. Digna Velez Edwards | Room MCE 8380 B
Workshop
Mentoring
Mid career faculty
Senior faculty
January 14, 2027 | 12:00 pm (In-Person) Panel Discussion | Location TBA
EFS Seminar
Mentoring
Pre/Post Doc
Early career faculty
January 28, 2027 | 12:00 pm (Virtual) Dr. Stephany Duda and Dr. Alvin Jeffery
EFS Seminar
Productivity
Life Hacks
Pre/Post Doc
Early career faculty
January 29, 2027 | 9:00 am (In-Person) Student Life Center
Forum
Doing Research
Pre/Post Doc
Early career faculty
Mid career faculty
Senior faculty
February 4, 2027 | 12:00 pm (In-Person) Panel Discussion | Location TBA
EFS Seminar
Grants & Funding
Writing & Publishing
February 18, 2027 | 12:00 pm (Virtual) Dr. Alvin Jeffery
EFS Seminar
Faculty Life
Pre/Post Doc
Early career faculty
February 25, 2027 | 12:00 pm (Virtual) Dr. Evan Brittain
EFS Seminar
Faculty Life
Early career faculty
March 4, 2027 | 12:00 pm (Virtual) Dr. Antentor Hinton
EFS Seminar
Writing & Publishing
Pre/Post Doc
Early career faculty
Testimonials
Success

Assistant Professor

Department
Anesthesiology; Biomedical Informatics
Award Type
  • R01

Assistant Professor

Department
Medicine (Cardiovascular Medicine)
Award Type
  • ASCI Physician Scientist Award

Assistant Professor

Department
Obstetrics & Gynecology, Division of Quantitative & Division of General Obstetrics
Award Type
  • K01 Recipient
Assistant Professor
Department
Health Policy/Pharmacoepidemiology
Award Type
  • R01



find out first